The Lisbon Treaty - A surprising winner from the financial crisis?

by Julia Lieb (Guest)

arrow

Second part of our series on the winners and losers of the current crisis  

Only a few months ago, most observers would have been very sceptical whether the Lisbon Treaty could be saved with a second Irish referendum. While now property prices in Dublin are falling like bricks and unemployment and the budget deficits are skyrocketing, also the mood towards the Lisbon Treaty has changed.

Again a poll that indicates a majority support for the Lisbon Treaty among Irish voters: 55 percent of the people asked would support the treaty, 37 percent would oppose it (Irish Sunday Independent/Quantum Research, 9 January 2009). This is the kind of news that causes optimism among supporters of the Lisbon Treaty – in solving the “Irish problem”, the process of ratification could be completed and the reforms implemented. But how to explain this change in public opinion? Is it – as willingly argued by Irish officials – an outcome of the decisions of the European Council in December 2008?

In the run-up to the summit, the Irish government had commissioned a study on the reasons for voting against the Lisbon Treaty. According to this study, the main reason for Irish voters opposing the Treaty was lacking or incorrect information on the Treaty content, followed by a fear of loss of autonomy, of Irish influence and of national identity within the European Union. At the European Council, the Irish Prime Minister obtained a series of concessions from his European counterparts. In order to secure a second Irish referendum on the Lisbon Treaty, “legal guarantees” were promised, stating autonomy of national taxation policy, education and family policy as well as respect of Irish neutrality. In fact, however, these “guarantees” just confirmed the actual Lisbon Treaty content. The only substantive concession given by the Heads of State and Government was to abandon the objective to downsize the European Commission by 2014.

The European Council aimed at responding to the above mentioned study results. Yet, to what extent do the reasons for opposing the Treaty put forward by the Irish government, which were hardly questioned by their European partners, reflect a realistic spectrum of Irish opinion? A glance at other surveys (for example Red C for the Sunday Business Post or Eurobarometer) leads to a much more differentiated picture and underlines the complexity of public opinion.

At present, it might be more realistic to bear in mind the effects of current international crises – such as the Georgian crisis – and in particular the economic and financial crisis. Against that background, political actors never tire to underline the added value of the Lisbon Treaty. The Reform Treaty would strengthen the capacity to act and the efficiency of the European Union in handling European and international crisis. The idea of the Union as a shield against external challenges seems to be becoming more accepted by citizens as well.

All the more in Ireland where, currently, secured wealth is threatened by economic decline.This fact might be especially graphic in the case of the current financial crisis which has hit Ireland already harder than any other country in the European Monetary Union. Already in 2008, Irish GDP has contracted by 2.0 per cent, the European Commission  forecasts a further decline of 5 percent in 2009 and continuing stagnation into 2010. The budget deficit has already reached more than 6 percent of GDP and is expected to reach climb to double digit-numbers in 2009 and 2010. Were Ireland now outside the euro-area, its government bonds most likely would have lost already their investment grade long ago. Instead, the rating agency Standard and Poor’s so far has only warned that it might downgrade Ireland from its current AAA rating. A current joke among Dublin bankers which compares Ireland to Iceland (“What is the difference between Iceland and Ireland? One letter.”) is thus only partly true: Thanks to its membership in EMU and the EU, financial markets to a large extent have kept confidence in Ireland even though public finances and the banking system of the small island now lie in shambles. Were it not for being member in the European Monetary Union, Ireland might now well even need to call in the International Monetary Fund for help. The – and the population is aware of this dire situation given the fact that a possible IMF program has already been brought into the debate in the recent wage negotiations.

Recent polls indicating that a majority of Irish voters are in favour of the ratification of the Lisbon Treaty might therefore only underline the fact that European integration at present is supported by external factors and not by internal manoeuvres. Having said this, the reform process of the European Union might just benefit from the current crisis.

Comments

  1. Robert
    March 17th, 2009 | 11:06 am

    EU: Article 11.4 of the Lisbon Treaty could be the key for solving the European democracy problem. What will happen, if it can be done, when several million votes are collected concerning a specific topic? What if, should there be that many articulated voices, the Commission has to listen to them and then act? These are the questions which “We Change Europe” would like to answer with their initiative.

    By this, we are entering completely new territory in Europe, since experiences with truly pan-European campaigns and referenda do not exist until now.

    The Union can overcome its democratic crisis only with help from the European citizens.

    The EU does not give its citizens a voice. The Europe needs Initiative association recognizes this as a threat to the Union’s future. “We Change Europe” are convinced that it is time to take initiative and to invigorate the concept of a European Citizens’ Democracy.

    “We Change Europe” wants to offer the opportunity of getting involved into the process of political decisions made in the EU. Therefore they created an E-Voting tool and the possibility to promote political aims in form of paneuropean initiatives.

    Topics, Europeans can vote for:
    The Europeans are enlarging their Union.
    The Europeans elect their President.

Leave a reply