EMU governance: sometimes it is better to say less….

by Daniela Schwarzer

Last Monday, French President Nicolas Sarkozy once again pushed for an old French idea, the "gouvernement économique" for the Eurozone. In his speech in front of the European Parliament, the acting EU Council President reinterated the French quest that the governance structures of the European Monetary Union should be strengthened in order to allow for more politics in the management of the Eurozone economy.

The idea is as old as the initial debates on the shape of EMU which were held in the 1980s and 1990s and which, in France, got revived by the Socialist candidate Lionel Jospin in the 2002 Presidential elections. While Nicolas Sarkozy himself was rather silent on the issue while acting as French Finance Minister under Jacques Chirac, he picked up this idea during his electoral campaign 2007 (just like Socialist candidate Ségolène Royal) linking his quest for closer economic cooperation with strong ECB bashing. Since elected to office, the latter point of critising the ECB is less present in the President's discourse. But the idea to improve EMU governance structures remained a point on the political agenda of Nicolas Sarkozy, ever since he moved into the Elysée Palace.

The first year of his Presidential term yet brought no progress in this direction - but not because Paris did not raise the issue. At some point in time, French officials had even ventilated EMU governance as a potential priority for its current EU Presidency. But France failed to contruct a consensus among the E(M)U partners - not over practical details, but worse, over the question whether this was at all an issue. Berlin and Paris raised arms over the topic of EMU governance in autumn 2007 in the context of other bilateral disputes, e.g. over the Mediterranean Union. It seemed that the French government was not only lacking the tactical skills to bring together key partners on this issue, but had no concrete proposal what it meant by installing an economic government, or for instance what a Eurozone summit should do and why. Each time French politicians brought up the issue, the German government (and media) immediately killed the idea. The German government did so partly with wrong arguments, suggesting that Sarkozy's one and only goal was to increase political influence on the ECB, while there was no decent reason to think about EMU governance structures. Henceforth, the issue disappeared from the agenda of an otherwise packed French EU Presidency.

The current financial crisis came as a catalyst for this political endeavor. Nicolas Sarkozy has de facto presided the first ever Eurogroup summit of EMU Heads of State and Government in October. The pressure to deal with the collapsing E(M)U banking market was so high that no country refused to come. Moreover, the fact that the Eurozone summit was part of a series of other international meetings camouflaged the historical uniqueness of the meeting to a certain degree.

France should now do what it can to make the Eurozone summit more than a one-off meeting. The window of opportunity is now open, but will not remain so for long: Firstly, France has only two months to go in its EU Presidency, before handing over the stick to the Czech Republic which will be seconded by Sweden in the second half of 2009, hence two countries which neither have any stakes in the EMU, nor are they among those countries that would push institutional or governance debate in oder to deepen integration. Secondly, the sense of urgency caused by the financial crisis may make EMU governments, including Germany, more open to pondering together further reaching issues than the rescue package for the banks. EMU-wide structures for banking supervision, financial market regulation, the future of fiscal policy coordination in the EMU - all these are issues of immediate relevancy to the EMU countries, not only for their internal matters, but also because the EMU and the EU should have a strong interest to take a common and forceful position in the upcoming debates on a Bretton Woods II and the more profound questions linked to the future of the global financial and economic system. Thirdly, the financial crisis has turned into a real economic crisis the effects of which will be felt in the EMU in the coming months and years. The expected tensions are not merely of an economic nature, but could very likely cause political turmoil as countries affected most may become difficult partners to deal with: take for instance Ireland which in December has to come up with a answer on the questions how it plans to proceed with the Lisbon Treaty, take Italy, which already now has a problem of competitiveness in the EMU - and a Prime Minister Berlusconi who has previously tagged the Euro as one of the biggest problems for Italy, take Spain or Portugal, which are likely to further cyclically diverge from the EMU average. In order to cope with political tensions, but also in order to push forward the necessary debate on how the EMU will be able to respond to the economic crisis and which structures it needs to ensure convergence and sustainable growth in the medium and long-term, a top-level meeting of EMU leaders should become a permanent forum.

Sarkozy's push for a debate on EMU governance structures serves the interest of all EMU members well. However, the French intuition that EMU needs politics should not be taken too far at this very time - as the danger persists that some EMU countries, especially Germany, turn their back on a French President seen as too pushy and interventionist. The best thing at this time is to say less, than to say more: At the end of his speech in front of the European Parliament on Monday, Sarkozy suddenly argued for a stronger involvement of European governments as shareholders in key strategic industries - after having made important points on EMU and global economic governance previously. The idea to increase public stakes in key industries reads for many as very much in line with "French interventionism" which some key decision-makers in Berlin strongly refuse and which has been a topic of constant Franco-German dispute over the last decades. The political and media reactions to Sarkozy's speech in Germany hence showed a wellknown pattern: The press mostly reported on Sarkozy's attempt to "renationalise key industries" and cited key German policy makers on this issue. This once again blurred the attempt to take the debate on EMU governance and EMU's position in the upcoming global debates a step further and makes it all to easy for policy-makers to brush away the necessary initiative to revise the governance structures of the EMU.

Comments

  1. October 24th, 2008 | 9:38 am

    While there is need for improved governance of economic and monetary union, initiatives leading to national(ist) responses or more intergovernmental structures are self-defeating in the end.

    Safeguarding and enhancing prosperity has to be laid on foundations of accountability, legitimacy and democracy.

  2. JLS
    October 24th, 2008 | 3:45 pm

    “initiatives leading to national(ist) responses or more intergovernmental structures are self-defeating in the end. ”

    I don’t understand initiatives are only either nationalist or intergovernmental.
    If you can’t work with others (best choice in my opinion) you do it alone.

Leave a reply